Plans to set up six pitches in Birdham for gypsies/travellers have been deferred by Chichester District Council.
James Chatfield, has used the paddock he owns off Pinks Lane to graze horses for many years, but now wants to change its use.
But yesterday, councillors decided to postpone making a decision on his planning application until more information about foul and surface water drainage was received.
While officers recommended the plans for approval, the committee had some concerns.
They decided, by five votes to three, to defer the application
As well as drainage, they were also worried about the right of way onto the site, given that Pinks Lane is privately owned.
Neighbours, including some living in Pinks Lane, have objected, saying the road is too narrow for caravans to access the paddock.
The application refers to passing points on the lane which could be used by caravans and other vehicles if necessary – but neighbours say these are privately owned.
Councillor Donna Johnson said she was worried that giving permission would “open up a legal minefield”.
Officers, though, said that was a civil matter not a planning matter.
The law says that anyone can apply for planning permission to build on anyone else’s land – but without consent from the owner, nothing can go ahead.
The council received a handful of objections to the plans, mostly concerning ownership and drainage, but also asking whether there was a need for the pitches.
A report to the committee said there was such a need.
According to the council’s gypsy, traveller & travelling show-people accommodation assessment, 121 plots are needed – 82 of them by the end of 2026.
To view the application, log on to publicaccess.chichester.gov.uk and search for 24/00727/FUL.
